Force Majeure vs. Impossibility: How the Two Defenses Differ
Force majeure is a contract clause: the parties wrote it, so its exact words decide what it covers. Impossibility is a common-law defense: a court applies it when no clause helps, and only when performance has become objectively impossible because of something nobody could have foreseen. Courts read both narrowly. A party that merely finds a contract harder, costlier or less profitable than expected will usually not be excused under either one.
That matters well beyond business deals. If you were hurt through someone else’s negligence, you may meet these terms in a service agreement, a lease, a ticket contract, a settlement paper or an insurer’s letter. Knowing what each one can and cannot do keeps you from accepting a bad excuse. At Calil Law, our trial attorneys handle personal injury, insurance dispute and complex commercial litigation in Florida, and we see how a party’s contract language shapes what happens next.
TL;DR
- Force majeure is a clause in the contract. It excuses or delays performance only for the events the clause describes, in the way it describes them.
- Impossibility is a default legal defense. It applies when performance is objectively impossible because of an unforeseeable event, and courts set that bar high.
- Higher cost is not enough. Being unprofitable, slower or more expensive rarely qualifies under either rule.
- Wording controls the outcome. Triggers, notice deadlines and a duty to minimize disruption often decide the case.
- If someone is using either excuse against you, have the contract reviewed before you accept it or sign anything.
Table of Contents
- What force majeure means
- What impossibility means
- Side-by-side comparison
- How courts read force majeure clauses
- What a well-drafted clause addresses
- What happens when there is no force majeure clause
- Where injured people run into these terms
- Practical steps if the other side invokes force majeure or impossibility
- Drafting protects you before a dispute
- Our perspective
- How Calil Law can help
- FAQ
- Sources
What force majeure means
Force majeure is French for “superior force.” In a contract, it is a clause that says what happens if an event outside a party’s control stops that party from doing what it promised. The clause might suspend the obligation, extend a deadline, or let one side cancel without penalty.
There is no single standard clause. Some list events: hurricanes, fires, strikes, government orders. Some add a catch-all such as “or other causes beyond the party’s reasonable control.” Some are very short. Because the parties wrote the language, the language is what a court enforces.
This is why force majeure is about allocating risk in advance. The parties decided together who would carry the burden if something unexpected happened, and a judge generally holds them to that deal.
What impossibility means
Impossibility (often grouped with impracticability and frustration of purpose) comes from case law, not from the contract. It applies by operation of law, even if the contract says nothing about it.
The classic example is a contract that depends on something that is destroyed, such as a building that burns down before a lease starts, or on a person who dies. The test is demanding. In Kel Kim Corp. v. Central Markets, New York’s highest court explained that impossibility requires an unanticipated event that could not have been foreseen or guarded against, and that the excuse is applied narrowly where a party could have contracted around the risk. Other states, including Florida, apply their own versions of these doctrines, so the details depend on where the contract is governed.
Three related ideas often get mixed together:
- Impossibility: performance cannot be done at all.
- Impracticability: performance is possible but would be extremely and unreasonably burdensome because of an unforeseen event. The bar is still high.
- Frustration of purpose: performance is still possible, but the reason both sides made the deal has been destroyed.
Side-by-side comparison
| Force majeure | Impossibility | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | The contract itself | Court-made law |
| Who writes the rules | The parties, in advance | Judges, case by case |
| What triggers it | The events the clause lists or describes | An unforeseeable event that makes performance objectively impossible |
| Does it need to be in the contract? | Yes | No, it applies by default |
| Notice requirements | Often, and strictly enforced | Usually none stated, but delay can hurt the claim |
| Typical effect | Suspension, extension or termination as the clause states | Excuse from performance, sometimes discharge of the contract |
| How courts read it | Narrowly, by the words used | Narrowly, with a heavy burden on the party raising it |
The practical rule: start with the contract. If a force majeure clause covers the event, that is where the analysis begins. If it does not, the party seeking to be excused may turn to impossibility, and it will have an uphill road.
How courts read force majeure clauses
Two decisions show how strict the reading can be.
In Kel Kim, the clause listed specific events such as power failures and equipment breakdowns, followed by a catch-all. The court held that a catch-all generally covers only events of the same kind as those specifically listed. The tenant could not get insurance, and the court found that this was materially different from the listed operational disruptions. The excuse failed.
In Avantax Wealth Management v. Marriott Hotel Services, the Sixth Circuit looked at a canceled June 2021 conference. It upheld the termination because a government letter gave reasonable grounds to conclude the event was illegal or impossible under the contract’s force majeure language. The result turned on the precise trigger and on how the contract measured notice, not simply on the fact that a pandemic was under way. Notice given ten days after the relevant letter was timely because the contract counted from the basis for termination.
The lesson from both cases is the same. Courts look at the exact words, the exact timeline and whether the event fits the clause.

What a well-drafted clause addresses
A clause that holds up usually answers several questions clearly. The World Bank’s public force majeure checklist recommends limiting relief to obligations actually prevented by the event, adding an express duty to minimize disruption, and requiring notice when the event is foreseen or becomes known. Put into everyday terms, a clause should say:
- Which events count. Named events, a defined category, or both.
- Which obligations are excused. Only the ones the event actually blocks, not the whole contract.
- How and when to give notice. Who must be told, in what form, and by what deadline.
- What the party must do to limit the damage. Courts and clauses often expect reasonable efforts to keep going or to recover.
- What happens next. Suspension, extension, a right to end the contract after a set time, or a refund.
If you are signing an agreement and one of these items is missing or vague, that is the moment to raise it, before the dispute, not after.
What happens when there is no force majeure clause
Without a clause, the party seeking relief falls back on the common-law defenses above. In general terms, that means arguing impossibility, impracticability or frustration of purpose under the law of the state that governs the contract. Each state has its own case law, and each places the burden on the party raising the excuse. The result is less predictable than a clear clause, and courts tend to ask whether the event was foreseeable and whether the party could have protected itself by writing a term into the contract.
Money trouble is the weakest argument. A decline in business, a supply price increase or a lender pulling out are risks that contracts usually place on the party who took the deal. If someone tells you they are excused because things became more expensive, that is not what these doctrines are designed to accommodate.

Where injured people run into these terms
Most people reading about this topic are not negotiating a supply contract. You are more likely dealing with one of these situations:
- A contractor, vendor or landlord says a hurricane, shortage or government order excuses a delay or a failure that contributed to your loss.
- A business involved in your accident points to a contract with another company to push responsibility elsewhere. Our guide on defend vs. indemnify explains how contracts between businesses can shift who answers a claim.
- A settlement or release agreement contains payment deadlines, and the other side says an outside event excuses a late payment.
- An insurer’s letter cites a policy provision or an outside event to justify delay or denial of a claim.
- A ticket or service agreement, such as for a cruise or a ride, includes terms that purport to limit what you can claim.
In each case, a label like “force majeure” or “act of God” does not decide anything by itself. What matters is whether the contract or policy actually says it, whether the event fits the words, whether notice was given as required, and whether the other side could have foreseen and guarded against it. Ordinary negligence is not an act of God. A wet floor, an unsafe truck or an unrepaired stairway are not forces of nature.
Insurance and contract risk
Businesses that take on contractual duties often carry insurance for the liability they accept in those contracts, and the requirements in the contract and the policy do not always line up. For a business owner, understanding contractual liability insurance is part of deciding which risks to accept in writing, which is the same risk-allocation question force majeure is meant to answer.
If an insurer relies on contract wording to delay or reduce your payment, see our pages on insurance claims and bad faith. Florida also has a civil remedy notice process for certain insurer conduct, and deadlines can affect your rights, as we explain in limitations vs. repose.
Practical steps if the other side invokes force majeure or impossibility
- Get the full contract. Read the clause itself, any definitions, the notice provision and the governing-law clause. A summary or a phone call is not enough.
- Compare the event to the wording. Is the event named? If the clause uses a catch-all, is the event the same kind as those listed?
- Check the timeline. Did the other side give notice when the contract required it? Late or missing notice can defeat the excuse.
- Ask whether the problem was foreseeable. If the risk was known or could have been guarded against, courts are skeptical.
- Look at what was actually prevented. An event that blocks one obligation does not excuse unrelated ones.
- Keep records. Save emails, letters, invoices, photos and dates. Evidence disappears quickly.
- Do not sign a release or amendment under pressure. A new agreement can replace your rights. Have it reviewed first.
Many of these disputes start as claims that are weakened by avoidable errors. Our article on why injury claims fail covers common ones.
Drafting protects you before a dispute
If you run a business, the best time to deal with unexpected events is before they happen. Clear notice terms, a defined list of events, a requirement to minimize disruption and a stated consequence all reduce room for argument. Remedies for late performance matter too: a damages term must be reasonable to be enforced, which we cover in our article on liquidated damages vs. penalty.
Our perspective
We read contracts the way a jury will hear about them: through plain words and a clear timeline. When someone says an unforeseen event excuses what they promised, our first question is not what happened in the world. It is what they wrote, when they said it and what they could have done about it.
Courts do not rescue a party from a bad bargain. That cuts both ways. It means a careless excuse should not stand in the way of a person who was wronged, and it means your own agreements deserve careful attention before you sign them.
Our firm is led by a Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer and Supreme Court Certified Mediator with over 18 years of Florida experience. We prepare each matter as one that may be tried to a verdict, because a position built for trial is also a stronger position at the negotiating table. You speak directly with the attorneys handling your matter, and every case is personally reviewed.
If a contract, a policy or an excuse stands between you and what you are owed, bring it to us. Your rights have value, and we will tell you plainly where you stand.
Jorge
How Calil Law can help
When a contract dispute, an insurance denial or an injury claim is on the table, we review the documents, the timeline and the facts, and we explain your options in plain language. We represent individuals and businesses in serious personal injury, insurance dispute and commercial litigation matters across Florida, and we charge no upfront fees: our revenue comes when a client receives a settlement or court award.
Start with the page that fits your situation: personal injury, insurance claims, or reach us through calillaw.com.

FAQ
Is force majeure the same as an act of God?
No. “Act of God” is a type of event, such as a flood or earthquake. Force majeure is a contract clause, and it may or may not list natural events. Whether a given storm counts depends on the clause’s wording and on whether the event actually prevented performance.
What is the difference between impossibility and impracticability?
Impossibility means performance cannot be done at all. Impracticability means it can be done, but only at an extreme and unreasonable burden caused by an unforeseen event. Courts treat both strictly, and higher cost alone is generally not enough.
Does force majeure cover war, a pandemic or a government order?
Only if the clause says so, or if the event fits the kind of events the clause lists. In Kel Kim, a catch-all was limited to events of the same kind as those named. In Avantax, a government letter and the contract’s wording were central to the outcome.
What if the contract has no force majeure clause?
The party seeking to be excused must rely on common-law defenses such as impossibility, impracticability or frustration of purpose, under the law of the governing state. That is harder to win than relying on a clear clause, because courts look closely at foreseeability.
Can a force majeure clause stop me from recovering for an injury?
A clause in a business contract generally deals with performance of that contract, not with negligence that injured you. Whether any contract term affects your claim depends on its exact words and the facts, so have the document reviewed by an attorney before relying on it either way.
Sources
- Kel Kim Corp. v. Central Markets, Inc., 70 N.Y.2d 900 (1987)
- Avantax Wealth Management, Inc. v. Marriott Hotel Services (6th Cir. 2024)
- World Bank PPP, Force Majeure Checklist and Sample Wording (April 2008)